3 Reasons Why Your Kid’s Good Grades Won’t Pay for College

apple and chalkboard representing good grades won't get you a great scholarshipMost people know that good grades will get you into college. And maybe if they’re good enough (along with an appropriate essay and the right extracurriculars and recommendations), they might get you into your dream or reach college. But while good grades may get you into your dream college, chances are they won’t pay for it with academic scholarships. This often comes as a surprise to students and their families but it really shouldn’t. There are 3 common situations where students aren’t going to qualify for enough academic scholarships to pay for college.

p id=’32754′]Dowload list of colleges that don’t offer merit scholarships here

1. You think your student just has to apply for private academic scholarships to pay for college.

Most private scholarship awards are only in the $500 to $1,000 range. This means that students would have to win at least 5 to 10 of these academic scholarships to start making a dent in the tuition for just your public state universities. In order to win 10 scholarships, how many scholarships do you think you have to apply to? According to Kevin Ladd from Scholarships.com:

…if you’re really good you might win one out of every six scholarships you apply for. If you’re average you might get one out of ten. If your circumstance is unusual you might get a higher ratio, but typically if you want to win ten scholarships to pay for 90% of your need, you’re going to have to apply to five to ten times that many to win them.

This means that students can expect to win about one out of every ten scholarships they apply for. Accumulating $10,000 in scholarships probably represents winning around 20 scholarships. To win those scholarships, a student has been applying to 5 to 10 scholarships a week for five months. How many scholarships does the average student find that she’ll even qualify for? And since most scholarships are for one year only, they’ll have to do this every year. The fact is that very few students manage to pay for college with private scholarships.

The ones who do treat it like a part-time job. They are reviewing and applying to scholarships on a weekly basis. They have a system set up to track all the elements of the scholarship application. They have developed strategies to pursue those that provide the most money for the least amount of effort. And they’re likely to attend a public university in a state that sponsors a merit scholarship system for state residents that will cover a significant amount of tuition.

2. Your student’s academic credentials aren’t in the top 25% of freshman accepted at the college.

Too often the fact that a student is accepted into a college is the only “reward” a student should expect from the college. Yes, your teen may have great grades and test scores. But are they substantially better than everyone else’s that attends the colleges she’s applying to?

This is a case of going from being a big fish in a little pond, high school, to a little fish in a big pond, college. While a student’s grades may be good enough to get her into the big pond, they aren’t going to cause her to stand out among all the other fish going to the big pond. And if she doesn’t stand out, she’s not likely to receive any substantial merit or academic scholarships from the school. (If you really want to find full ride scholarships, start here.)

3. Your teen only applies to colleges ranked in the top 50 of US News Best College Rankings.

I’m not going to get into whether or not the top ranked colleges actually represent the best college education possible. What I’m certain they do represent is popularity among high school students. These are schools everyone wants to go to, whatever the reasons. So the schools have their pick of students to fill their classes which is why their acceptance rates are so low.

Therefore, these colleges generally don’t offer merit scholarships. Even if your teen is in the top 25% of academic qualifications, he’s not likely to get an academic scholarship. The reason is simple, he can easily be replaced with another student just as qualified. And let’s face it, when the lower 25th percentile of a class ranks in the 90th percentile nationally or higher, it’s pretty hard for students to distinguish themselves academically.

Students and parents need to understand this, the most competitive colleges offer no or limited merit scholarships for students. They are not going to reward your student’s academic achievements except by allowing him to attend.

You can check their websites. They will either say financial aid awards are based on need only or only have a limited number of merit-based scholarships available. If the college has their Common Data Set information posted, you can check to see the number of students receiving non-need institutional grants and the average amount. You can download a list of colleges that don’t offer merit scholarships here.

Which students will get academic scholarships that will significantly help cut the cost of college?

The students who get academic scholarships are those that apply to colleges offering money to convince them to attend.

These are colleges where students who don’t break into the 85th percentile in national test scores, still have a chance to attend.

These are colleges that are located in less popular areas. That means not in the northeast, popular urban areas, or on the west coast.

These are colleges that don’t break the top 50 of national college rankings. They are trying to improve their brand recognition rather than just protect it.

In other words, the students who get significant academic scholarships do so by sacrificing  prestige and name recognition for affordability. Just remember, this is not the same thing as sacrificing academic quality.

One last thing to keep in mind. We’re talking about averages here. There will always be some students who win just four outside scholarships that pay the way to Stanford. These stories inevitably make the local and often national news. They do so because they don’t happen every day–they are the exception.

3 Reasons Why Your Kid\'s Good Grades Won\'t Pay for College